you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]SnowAssMan 9 insightful - 2 fun9 insightful - 1 fun10 insightful - 2 fun -  (2 children)

This is just dwelling on intersex exceptions again. GC don't make up their own definitions when it comes to sex. Just Wiki that shit if you want to know the GC view, because funnily enough there's quite a lot of overlap between science & GC feminism, which is an understatement.

It's you guys who go on about chromosomal sex, vs. gonadal sex, vs. hormonal sex vs. anatomical sex – check, check, check, check – trans-womxyn's sex is male on every count. So by your own standards trans-womxyn still end up being male & not intersex & certainly not female.

No definition of the female sex, no matter how liberal, will include trans-womxyn's unambiguously male sex, sorry. Intersex exceptions aren't remotely relevant. Most trans-womxyn, just like most people, are endosex, not intersex.

Say there was a possibility that trans-womxyn could be considered female, despite matching the definition of male by both lacking every female sexual organ & having every male sexual organ, it would backfire. Once you erode the differences between the sexes you're left with no justification to distinguish between trans-womxyn & men again. Back to square one.

You can't convince us that a medically transitioned trans-woman is equivalent to intersex, if that's what you meant. You should really change your slogan to reflect your true beliefs: "only medically transitioned trans-womxyn are women" since that what the hive mind seems to suggest every time you go down the "WhatAboutIntersex road", which you all invariably do e.g. "hormonally trans-womxyn are the same as women, therefore blah, blah, blah".

[–]ColoredTwiceIntersex female, medical malpractice victim, lesbian 9 insightful - 1 fun9 insightful - 0 fun10 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

Intersex conditions in most cases are sex specific and happens only for males or females. In all cases we are still male or female.

Assigning sex at birth - was medical malpractice, when medical personnel was not wanting to be bothered enough to make more tests, or was unqualified to make correct judgement. I am victim of one. And often this was leading to IGM, health issues and even death from lack of correct treatment.

Sex is aspectrum is saying we are lesser females or lesser males, or something in-between. It is very dehumanizing and very triggering. Ant it is just a lie, we are either female or male. Fully.

People born with Congenital Disorders of Sex Development (intersex) are no less female or male, same as people born with Congenital Heart Disorders are no less humans.