I'm afraid arguing with you is a waste of time, as you're clearly trying to promote a per-existing conclusion (or agenda, be that as it may) rather than actually argue why the solution wont work (which you cannot do, because resisting shills is objectively better for any site than leaving them unchecked).

Hope whoever sees this meaningless discussion comes over /s/ShillWall for some resources on how to identify shills, and information regarding what they can do to help saidit.