you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]strictly 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

Also, in this reddit post is a fun little thought excercise in this regard https://www.reddit.com/r/truscum/comments/ll6tpa/we_need_to_start_asking_transphobes_what_they/

That thought experiment doesn’t make sense. This person obviously want to prove female people have “female gender identities” and would be dysphoric if they woke up as male. But the argument of this person makes is that waking up as an estrogenized male would be worse for a person with a “female gender identity” than waking up as a non-estrogenized male. If that’s the case, why would males with so called “female gender identities” want to transition to estrogenized males, if staying non-estrogenized is better for those with “female gender identities”? Shouldn’t they instead argue that female people who wake up as non-estrogenized males also would want to take estrogen and become estrogenized?

Either way, to me the estrogenized male body is the most visually unappealing body configuration (nothing against those who are attracted to that body type or like having that body type though). So yes, I wouldn’t like waking up with a “girl dick” or inverted penis. If I am going to be male I would much prefer to be non-estrogenized male, and if I am going to have penis I would prefer the non-inverted one. My first act if I woke up as an estrogenized male would be to detransition the body. And yes, I would regard myself as male if I woke up male, a male with a female past, so I would be different from other natural males as I in this magical scenario would be a magical male (made male by magic, not due to nature).