She has her foibles, for instance when she talks about children being “transed” she seems to always say “parents” and not mothers, who we all know are responsible for it in the vast majority of cases. Also her focus seems to be squarely on the harm to women and girls and very little on the damage being done to young boys and men who get caught up in this, her position seems to be that trans-identifying men are responsible for their own transing whilst trans-identifying women are just victims of it, which seems to be a widely held belief amongst the gender critical crowd.

Saying that, I found her book to be excellent and have time for what she says even if her perspective is not entirely aligned with mine.

She has the academic clout that Parker Posie lacks, and she isn’t as confrontational despite making the exact same points.