As someone who was in OP's boat about four years ago, just lose the damn labels. I went from progressive to liberal but not progressive to independent, to libertarian, back to independent.. I'll probably vote republican this year, but I wont call myself a republican because it comes with a whole lot of assumed stances I don't agree with. There isn't a label for what I am now, and at the end of the day, there's probably not a label for anyone who doesn't blindly align with a lot of views they haven't thought through because those topics weren't their priority.