you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]haveanicedaytoo💗💜💙 30 insightful - 1 fun30 insightful - 0 fun31 insightful - 1 fun -  (2 children)

She didn't even realize she was bisexual until two seconds ago. THIS is exactly what I mean when I talk about "Confused bisexuals." Now this barely-bi woman thinks she's entitled to write about gay boys (not even BI boys, which, oddly enough, I'd be personally okay with, though it's not up to me to be okay with it) she is obviously a closeted yaoi/slash fan, who felt the need to write a story about cute boys doing cute things together, and there weren't any gay men on this entire planet who could write that story so she had to be the one to do it, what a hero.

If you can't tell, I'm annoyed.

It's extremely convenient for her to realize she's bi, when she's married and already knows she will never come face-to-puss with another woman. I'm not saying she's lying because actually she is a perfect example of my "Confused bisexuals" wall-of-text I wrote the other day here:

https://saidit.net/s/LGBDropTheT/comments/6aja/an_idea_with_questions/oe0u

But I do feel like there is a HUUUUGE difference between her and a bisexual woman who's known she was bi her whole life and actually dated and had sex with both men and women. (And please nobody feel bad if this doesn't describe you and you're still bi, there's a million different ways to be bi.)

An analogy I can give is this. Imagine a girl from Korea who was adopted as a baby, doesn't speak a lick of Korean, grew up in an all-white environment, completely removed from Korean culture blah blah blah. She is going to have a unique life experience that isn't going to be like the typical Korean-American experience at all. So when she decides to write a novel about Korean-Americans and it's all kim-chi and K-pop, and plastic surgery and other cliches, and on-top of that, getting a lot of things wrong and offending other Korean people, what do you even say in that situation? Here is a woman who knows fuck-all about being bisexual, writing novels about it. I'm basing this solely on her saying she just realized she's bi at 37. Not the fact that she's never been with a woman. I know a lot of bi women/men have never been with the same sex. That's not the issue. This feels like she did a DNA test and found out she's half Korean and decided to write a novel about being a Korean-American girl just based on that. It feels really hollow/shallow.

Here is what she knows about: Staying in the closet her entire life and not even realizing she was bi. (If she is actually bi.)

Here is the elephant in the room: The reason she had to come out was not because readers had a problem with her being straight, it's because they had a problem with her being straight and writing gay, lesbian, and bisexual characters in unrealistic ways that didn't feel authentic. Saying "Well, I'm bisexual too, so there!" doesn't really fix the situation that those characters still suck and they're still unrealistic and don't feel like real gay/bi/lesbian teens/adults.

[–]8bitgay 23 insightful - 1 fun23 insightful - 0 fun24 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

Now this barely-bi woman thinks she's entitled to write about gay boys (not even BI boys, which, oddly enough, I'd be personally okay with, though it's not up to me to be okay with it)

Right? It's a bit weird how people act like LGBTQ is interchangeable. Oh, she's a bi woman, so she also knows the experiences of gay guys by osmosis.

I mean, frankly I think people should write about whatever they want, otherwise gay people wouldn't be able to write about straight people either. Although of course writing about what you know might make it more believable and personal - and in this case writing about gay guys isn't part of a bi woman's personal experiences.

If she said something like "I'm not a gay man but as a writer I can write about characters who aren't like me", I'd be fine with that. Using the bi card though is way worse and even offensive, as it acts like we're all the same thing.

[–]les4leshomonormative 8 insightful - 1 fun8 insightful - 0 fun9 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

Oh, she's a bi woman, so she also knows the experiences of gay guys by osmosis.

LMAO this is the most annoying thing. To harp on the original comment's Korean analogy it's like claiming that she understands Japanese or Vietnamese culture because she's familiar with Korean culture, and the original comment already discusses how she probably isn't