Good critique, much better than the drivel MSM articles attempting to debunk this. It does seem like Hersch's reporting here is kind of sloppy considering its one of the very few pieces of this sort to get any kind of mainstream attention. If you are going to obviously open yourself up to fire from the establishment by attacking them using your Pullitzer cred, you'd think you wouldn't want to play so fast and loose with the facts.

Thanks for sharing this piece, appreciate being able to get a reasonable critique of this