Why TRAs Will Fail: Medical vs Spiritual Arguments by assignedcopatbirth in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 4 insightful - 2 fun4 insightful - 1 fun5 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

This is an honest & provocative deconstruction. It confronts the nature of TRA arguments with ease. I haven’t seen anyone suggest “spirituality” as the foundational partner of their (loose & fast) “medical” arguments. It doesn’t surprise me that I haven’t seen it before, given science (reality) is yet still eschewed in favor of ignorance & delusion.

I saved it for the future. I already know I’m going to consult it tomorrow, bc the antithetical nature of the spiritual/medical argument is something that occupies a lot of my criticism towards 12-step programs’ overwhelming presence as a blanket solution to addiction — despite it being a spiritual program with a spiritual approach towards addiction that cannot co-exist alongside the current disease model. I talk often with other gender critical addicts & can’t wait to discuss this with them. It’s actually strange to meditate on the similarities between AA/TRA communities. (No coincidence obviously that many of these men - TIMs - are addicts).

Thank you for taking the time to craft this. Perhaps a little over-dramatic of me...but I think bc you gave language to illusory feelings I had — about how addiction is treated & what this means for myself & others — I’m extra appreciative. Your thoughts & ideas will stay with me for a long time. I’m very grateful for that. Thank you.

Feminity is... Wearing a fluffy robe that's pink by [deleted] in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 6 insightful - 2 fun6 insightful - 1 fun7 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

Way back when, GC linked to some fetish site where autogynephilic TIMs dished about: freezing tomato juice & putting it up their ass, then wearing a pad (to “mimic” a period.......); stealing used tampons/pads from the garbage in women’s bathrooms to put up their ass; graphic accounts of using said stolen-products. Fucked up

The document that reveals the remarkable tactics of trans lobbyists | The Spectator by yishengqingwa666 in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 8 insightful - 2 fun8 insightful - 1 fun9 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

Fucked up. When I read comprehensives of TRA’s approach, I feel hopeless. Clearly the cross-dressing/fetish millionaires are having a ball with the amount of power they possess. The fact that all of these children think they’re so socially aware as to see the signs of fascism when they can’t even follow a simple money trail is beyond me. Sometimes, man...sometimes I honestly wouldn’t mind going back to living beneath the underpass & shooting dope & not seeing the complete destruction of female, sex-exclusive rights. Out there it wouldn’t matter anyways. Sometimes I wish I wasn't so angry.

Mermaids organisation suggests J K Rowling caused suicides by turtleduck23 in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 28 insightful - 1 fun28 insightful - 0 fun29 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

You’re both right. Bisexual & lesbian are exclusive sexualities. Yet additionally: in growing as a human being & having experiences, you thought you were bisexual at one point, lesbian at another; there is of course nothing wrong with that.

If I may say so... I don’t think just_lesbian_things was challenging your right to discern your sexuality over the course of your life. They themselves were clearly protective in their comment of the term “lesbian,” and who can blame them given how its ‘definition’ includes attraction to men nowadays.

It wasn’t clear at all in this small sentence fragment what the combination of the two sexualities meant—the “/“ just made it seem as though “bisexual/lesbian” was your sexuality. It didn’t connote a distinction between them to me.

Seems like a miscommunication. You explained what you meant & it wasn’t that you were simultaneously bisexual & lesbian, therefore rendering just_lesbian_things’ comment irrelevant to your reply. I can’t know how painful & confusing it must have been for you during that time. People are eager to misunderstand you when you’re a young woman, even more so when you’re gnc. I would be a dog off the leash to anyone who tried to tell me who I am; I really do understand where you’re coming from, even if I can’t know completely all you’ve been through. I really don’t think there’s any ill-intent here. We’re all protective of who we are as lesbians & Im glad for that. I hope I didn’t overstep any boundaries in commenting on this exchange—just felt like I might be able to help. Famous last words

''Sorry, gender critical content is too offensive'' Meanwhile Reddit: by [deleted] in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 5 insightful - 1 fun5 insightful - 0 fun6 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

All porn is rape porn.

''Sorry, gender critical content is too offensive'' Meanwhile Reddit: by [deleted] in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 4 insightful - 1 fun4 insightful - 0 fun5 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

Conservatives and intelligence do not go together.

A mother discussing losing her daughter to transgender ideology gets removed from YouTube for "hate speech" by [deleted] in censorship

[–]crazyangryfemale 6 insightful - 2 fun6 insightful - 1 fun7 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

Amish men have children, rape their female children, let their male children rape their female children, rape other female children, & no female child-adolescent-or-adult is allowed to speak about it within the community

https://www.cosmopolitan.com/lifestyle/a30284631/amish-sexual-abuse-incest-me-too/

the clothes-stealing, lesbian-obsessed, AGP crossdresser creep currently suing the state of Idaho for access to women's locker rooms. by gparmesan in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

This comment gives me the creeps. You’re way too excited to see some racist white dude pretend he’s black.

Men's Health magazine. How to choke a woman. I don't want to live on this planet. by our_team_is_winning in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 3 insightful - 2 fun3 insightful - 1 fun4 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

Thank you!! There’s nothing for someone like this on a feminist-based forum.

Men's Health magazine. How to choke a woman. I don't want to live on this planet. by our_team_is_winning in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 4 insightful - 1 fun4 insightful - 0 fun5 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

Sure, let’s blame women for not being smart enough. That’s productive. You’re giving a lot of room for men yet none for women. Men who commit these violent, misogynistic acts will likely be skilled liars & narcissists. They would have prowled & successfully convinced dozens of women that they’re safe when they’re not. Abusive men as well change their female partner’s brain with the abuse. Even without a background of abuse/trauma, any woman in the world can imbibe the messages we’re directly & purposefully fed about needing to be submissive & able to withstand torture. Women are shown through porn & common media that the sexiest woman can still smile & perform while being brutalized (though common media wont see BDSM as brutalization, it’s perspective). While I’m in favor of women arming themselves (as I don’t believe men will change) let’s not slide back in progress so far that we call women ignorant. I’m sure many women felt something. But we aren’t raised to trust that. As well, many women don’t know what these red flags look like. I’ve had so many conversations with women about men, how you can feel them out, even when they have a personality disorder that would complicate it; and many times all they need is for someone to teach them the language. I remember one women who had been abused for twenty years turning to look at me & saying “I’d never thought about it like that.” Don’t underestimate how deceit, manipulation, violence, & abuse can affect women’s ability to process threatening behavior.

You’re calling these women weak for being beaten to death & not having the mystical power of foresight to see it coming. Or are other women weak for being vulnerable & traumatized, deserving in their pursuit of bdsm? Mind clarifying that? We’re all accountable for our actions, but when we’re looking at a pattern of behavior in females who often share similar backgrounds or experiences, it’s shallow & ridiculous to pass it off as their weakness, ignorance, or stupidity.

Nearly 30% of men say progress toward gender equality has come at their expense, according to new report by questioningtw in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 25 insightful - 2 fun25 insightful - 1 fun26 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

That they whine whenever a small fraction of their resources is shared with the rest of the world shows how little they are “oppressed” under patriarchy. Men created & sustained this system. They have nothing to gain by helping women, only more to lose. I could give a shit if they have a hard time crying. Join the club. It’s no surprise that political affiliation makes no difference when it comes to men’s feelings towards women. With everything these men disagree on, they can at least agree that women deserve less.

My father used to give us small gifts as children as a means of manipulation & bargaining. “I did this for you. How will you show me you’re grateful? You’re not being grateful enough. You don’t appreciate me to my standards. I have to punish you.” Everything we received was a means to an end, a chain that kept us obligated to him somehow, which we unfortunately did not learn until we were older.

I see how men as a class interact with women in the same way. Men often say they “gave” us the right to vote, so we should show some gratitude by not asking for anything else, by being ladies, by being homemakers, being quiet, subservient, dogs. In their minds they desire all the control over their lives, which cannot co-exist with a woman who has all the control over her life, if he’s going to have a family with her. He needs to control her, too. And every woman is only worth her value as a wife or mother in their futures. How do you persuade men to give up control? You don’t...I can’t see majority support for women’s liberation from men. If it does happen all we would need is men in positions of government & legislature to support us. I’m not concerned with anything else.

The Saidit.net Terms and Content Policy by magnora7 in SaidIt

[–]crazyangryfemale 0 insightful - 2 fun0 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 2 fun -  (0 children)

Bruh. You need to log off for a bit.

Trans homicide epidemic is a false narrative. by koonay in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 5 insightful - 1 fun5 insightful - 0 fun6 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

Black & white thinking, all or nothing, is a tendency for almost everyone on Earth (I’d love to meet someone who is able to avoid it!) and it’s responsible for a lot of the behavior we see. TIMs & TIFs really...need to be center stage when it comes to ‘social justice,’ or discussion of current events. They’re always reminding the public of how marginalized trans people are, & how many trans women have been killed; as long as the public sees them as the most vulnerable, any scandal or scrutiny will be water off a duck’s back. The repetition of these same statements is to keep people convinced just enough that they truly are in danger & need help, & that’s why they got your favorite professor pulled from a conference on etymology...because they’re suffering. Side-note—this is really cynical of me, but: isn’t everyone suffering? Isn’t everyone in pain? /Nietzsche. Doesn’t everyone kinda sorta wish they had more hope for the future than they have right now? I used to think suffering was glamorized as an ideal state for social purposes; it seems sexual, financial, political gain are also part of the glamorization for TIMs. It’s not the “suffering” that is glamorous but what it gives them. Their dedication to being the sole, suffering minority could support a hypothetical desire for financial, political, & social gain—no one to share with.

Still...how? They’re nobody’s. Who are they to cast these sad spells? How did they come in & take something so important & precious?—because they’re men? because they already had wealth & power? because maybe some very powerful yet disturbed men want the world to be this way, & they are the ones who pull the strings in the background? TRAs have taken a lot of language & pissed on it, language that is important, that needs to mean what it means, so that we can say things when we open our mouths to speak! Of course they’ve taken language. They take words that carry weight & they use their power to change them; I can feel our fight against them with the word “woman” sometimes, like two fists connected only by the knucklebone & first three fingers. They’ve warped what it means to have PTSD & trauma...this is a red hot resentment for me. I hate how they’ve cheapened & trivialized prostitution & womanhood & the experience of being female. They never use gender & sex correctly, nor any relevant terms; the invention of new identities per every thought or feeling to emerge in someone’s head, as well as the expectation that everyone everywhere know of these abstract concepts & honor them. They’ve utilized language to a mind-numbing degree as a form of control. I don’t understand how other people who haven’t spent that much time with TRAs don’t see this. At best I feel crazy, at worst I feel like I’m on the Truman Show & even the TRAs who are “in denial” are actually aware and know that this is all a lie but they can’t renege on their deal for some reason. I digress.

TRAs see themselves as victims & anyone else who is not them is a possible aggressor; they can’t detect or tolerate nuance because if they were made aware of nuance, they would have to confront uncomfortable thoughts or feelings, & the brain works overtime to avoid pain. To avoid pain they have to lie. Lying is easy and feels good. In the beginning they spread their lie everywhere yet due to the niche nature of their ideology (cult)—mental illness—the curious ones weren’t doing their digging, & the public was only marginally enamored with the idea of TIMs as marginalized. While the public looked to the right, TRAs pocketed whatever common sense they had left, which wasn’t a whole lot. I remember thinking “how did a nation fall in love with this story so fast?” I couldn’t understand how TRAs were able to get everyone on board: politicians, press, academics, experts, scientists, lesbians, yes, I still feel hurt & betrayed by women I’ve known & loved & kissed & fucked & told my secrets to, who I feel so distant from now, women who had a belly big with fire & knew how to use it—to protect women, to fight for women, to liberate women. Now for men. And like I can guess why they do it—to avoid pain: if they confronted the truth & owned up to it, what else would they have to answer to? What would they have to take accountability for? Who would demand accountability from them except for us?—It’s difficult to say how social media & the press would adapt, only that they will adapt to whatever sells.

For some TRAs I’m sure avoidance of accountability is as good a reason as any to continue to propagate the idea that sex isn’t real (& if it were real (which it isn’t) it wouldn’t matter), women are the archetypal villain of this year’s Disney movie, & trans women LITERALLY are women, hunty. (/s) For everyone else though I truly believe a decent portion of the group knows they have a castle made of sand. They know TIMs aren’t dying at epidemic rates compared to the rest of the world but who cares? The reason why the death of these TIM prostitutes is so urgent is because it’s a validation tool, for the self & the other. The more it circulates that it’s dangerous to be trans, the more a trans individual can justify their victimhood, to themselves & possibly to other people who they are likely mistreating in some way. Every story—every lie, even though it’s a lie—being regurgitated en masse by media without any fact-checking is so fucking typical, yet it doesn’t lessen my fear. And now that grain by grain, lie by lie, they have this castle, I can see that just like a narcissist, the stories & the lies are not their focus in manipulating their victim. It’s community, us vs. them, you’re in or you’re out. Through camaraderie they established trust with other vulnerable, marginalized groups; this got them a lot of support. Aka $$$. TIMs know they’re not oppressed as men & that they’re opting into oppression by pretending to be women. Opting into this oppression, claiming it, & doing so with the empathy/support of other marginalized groups, lent TRAs credibility. That was smart of them to do. I don’t know if some of these men knew at the beginning that it wasn’t trans rights they were seeking, but a paycheck to fund, & laws to excuse, their obsessive-compulsive fetish & addiction. I’m sure some had that in mind.

What I find the most alarming is how TRAs were able to capitalize on the empathy &/or compassion others had for them. They used the nature of the community they had built, its function to connect, as a tool to create shame in others. We’ve seen this in history so many times. They didn’t invent it. But over the course of a few years, through a lot of banning, doxxing, harassing, firing, tweets, messages, late night phone calls, & nonstop texts, TRAs had built a community that had such stringent consequences for loyalty that it could hardly be considered an ideology or a human rights group. To use someone’s compassion for you as a tool to manipulate, use, & then discard when expectations are not met, is disgusting. All of this to fucking say: There’s no fucking way these men give a shit about other men dying on the street. They only care about themselves. They must. The only way any of this makes sense to me is if the majority of TRAs (so, TIMs. the men.) exhibit moderate to severe narcissistic tendencies or have APD/NPD. Some researchers believe narcissists can feel love, but choose to withhold it; others believe they feel nothing. From my experience I believe in the latter. Has anyone else (unfortunately) had extensive experience with a narcissist?

Gender Critical was extraordinary by milpathecat in GenderCritical

[–]crazyangryfemale 3 insightful - 1 fun3 insightful - 0 fun4 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

Your post gave me little tears in my eyes ❤️ Women have always persevered in spite of men, in spite of everything, & we’ll persevere now. GC meant a lot to me, too. I’m so glad to see so many women still in this fight together. It truly calms the cynicism always at risk of taking over in my brain. So proud of how far you’ve come and for all you’ve done for women, for us. Good luck to you & your sisters in Spain; my hands, my words, & my rage are with you all. I wish you the absolute best, sister! ❤️