all 15 comments

[–][deleted]  (6 children)

[deleted]

    [–]literalotherkinNorm MacDonald Nationalism 5 insightful - 1 fun5 insightful - 0 fun6 insightful - 1 fun -  (3 children)

    Great post. You should actually consider sending him this. From what I know the guy is open to robust but fair criticism like you're providing.

    [–][deleted]  (2 children)

    [deleted]

      [–]literalotherkinNorm MacDonald Nationalism 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

      I'm sure you can get in contact on Gab but here's his website: https://thealternativehypothesis.org/index.php/submit-an-article/

      [–]Nombre27 3 insightful - 1 fun3 insightful - 0 fun4 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

      Thank you, very informative.

      [–]casparvoneverecBig tiddy respecter 2 insightful - 3 fun2 insightful - 2 fun3 insightful - 3 fun -  (0 children)

      Our lord speaks to us once more

      [–]cisheteroscumWhite Nationalist[S] 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (5 children)

      So Ryan's main point with this vid of I understand correctly is that there was some marginal voter flip-flopping between Nazi and Communist parties in 1930s Germany - and that this goes to show the two ideologies are not necessarily diametrically opposed. In a broader sense, that the left/right divide is kind of fake and the Nazis being "far right" and the Communists "far left" is oversimplifying the issue. This lends support to his "cult-like" model of politics that he thinks better describes the phenomenon.

      I think this is largely unsurprising to us - but still an interesting vid, glad he's back at it again.

      [–]MarkimusNational Socialist 5 insightful - 1 fun5 insightful - 0 fun6 insightful - 1 fun -  (2 children)

      It's important to note also that the Communist parties in Germany were nationalistic and volkisch not libtard 'communism' we see today nor the jew/bolshevik shit we saw in the Spartacists and whatnot in Germany. It wasn't Volkisch socialists becoming rootless cosmopolitans who want to rape nuns and shit like the Bolsheviks and Spanish Red Terror. It was moreso National Socialists who thought that Hitler was too mild economically and in terms of the speed at which he was replacing the current elite class. Sadly reddit removed a bunch of stuff but Niekisch/Stennes (arplan.org guy) has posted redpills on this before. Also a LOT more Communists became Nazis than the other way around, and the Nazis that did become Communist were basically just NazBols anyway.

      [–]MarkimusNational Socialist 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

      Got a couple relevant comments from thethirdposition archive

      Stennes

      I can think of a few. They're not so famous today, but they were well-known figures in Germany during the '20s & '30s:

      Josef “Beppo” Römer - leader of the Freikorps Bund Oberland; later moved to the left, taking a portion of his men with him & becoming Rechtsbolschewisten ('Bolsheviks of the right'). Was executed during the Third Reich.

      Bodo Uhse - prominent NS journalist who took part in the Schleswig-Holstein Landvolk struggle. Grew disillusioned with the NSDAP, briefly left it for the Strasser-group, then joined the KPD. Became a famous writer in East Germany.

      Arnolt Bronnen - prominent Expressionist playwright who shocked his friends (including Bertolt Brecht) by moving from the left to support for the NSDAP. Was friends with Goebbels and hung out with Niekisch, Jünger, Otto Strasser, Ernst von Salomon. Was kind of an asshole. Struggled during the Third Reich because of suspected Jewish ancestry and became an ardent communist towards the end of WWII.

      Ernst Niekisch - started on the far-left (he was a significant figure in the Bavarian SPD & USPD), then moved towards national-revolutionary politics. He was treated abominably during the '30s (imprisoned & tortured by the Gestapo for suspected treason, suffered permanent vision damage). Became a communist again while locked up and was relatively high-up in the East German government, until he grew disillusioned after the crackdown on the Berlin Uprising and fled to West Germany.

      Bruno von Salomon - brother of famous nationalist writer Ernst von Salomon. Started off as a nationalist, supporting the peasants in the Landvolk struggle. He & Bodo Uhse converted to communism together. He fled Germany during the Reich and iirc died of alcoholism after the War.

      Richard Scheringer - Very famous case. Was a young junior officer in the Reichswehr. He and two friends (Hanns Ludin and Hans Wendt) were taken to court for spreading nationalist & NS propaganda amongst the soldiers. Hitler famously spoke at their trial; his words helped disillusion Scheringer. Scheringer was converted to communism while in jail (Ludin joined the SA after he was released; Wendt joined the Strasser-group). After Scheringer was released from jail he was used as propaganda by the communists to try and convert other nationalists. He stayed friends with Ludin; Ludin protected him during the Third Reich and they fought together in WWII. After the War Scheringer couldn't prevent the communist authorities in Czechoslovakia from demanding Ludin's death, although he tried. Scheringer became a prominent KPD/DKP (communist) politician in West Germany after the War. His children & grand-children are still prominent in the Left Party.

      Those are the most famous German cases I can think of right now, although I'm sure there are others. Most of them have Wiki pages with more info. There were lots of less-famous nationalist converts in Germany as well, though. The KPD adopted a new program in August 1930 which was specifically written to appeal to nationalists, to voters who might be lured to the NSDAP. Scheringer's conversion helped them - he became the face of their new 'national-bolshevik' campaign. In the 1931-to-early-1933 period especially there was a lot of drifting from Brown to Red (or vice versa, and sometimes back again...). The Strasser-group was kind of a transition-point for people switching from one side to the other, they'd often pass through it first (which I'm sure frustrated Otto). The NSDAP's strong socialist rhetoric, and the KPD's heightened nationalist rhetoric, created a confused situation - there were plenty of people who'd have been happy with either party in charge so long as they got socialism and a strong Germany again.

      Me

      Interesting, seems like most of them remained nationalist and just switched based on economic differences, kind of like how a left and right emerge in Liberalism or anywhere else I suppose. Are there any that went full International Socialist completely renouncing nationalism and race politics?

      Richard Scheringer - Very famous case. Was a young junior officer in the Reichswehr. He and two friends (Hanns Ludin and Hans Wendt) were taken to court for spreading nationalist & NS propaganda amongst the soldiers. Hitler famously spoke at their trial; his words helped disillusion Scheringer. Scheringer was converted to communism while in jail

      Can you explain this? Wouldn't Hitler have been defending him if he was spreading nationalist propaganda? How would Hitler have made him disillusioned? Sounds weird. Thanks for the comment btw, good info here.

      Stennes

      Interesting, seems like most of them remained nationalist and just switched based on economic differences... Are there any that went full International Socialist completely renouncing nationalism and race politics?

      This is my assessment too - they might have joined or supported the KPD, but they were basically National-Bolsheviks during the Weimar/Third Reich era. As far as I'm aware all of them who survived the Hitler-period did eventually renounce their earlier radical-nationalism after the War, though - Scheringer went from a gung-ho militarist to a strong advocate for peace and internationalism, for instance (although he never demanded the USSR disarm itself, of course, just the Western imperialists). Bronnen and Uhse became orthodox Marxist-Leninists who supported whatever the Soviet line was (although Uhse grew to have doubts). I'm not sure about Niekisch, since his ideas as a nationalist were so eccentric already, but I suspect like a lot of people the excesses of the NS era pushed him away from strong völkisch ideals. It's complicated by the emergence of East Germany, though - plenty of people (encouraged by the state) just swapped out their pan-German nationalism for a new patriotism towards the "socialist fatherland" of the DDR, bound up at the same time in the idea of "international socialist brotherhood" with other communist nations. Some examples of this nationalist/patriotic slogan in the DDR - unser sozialistisches Vaterland, 'our socialist fatherland'.

      Can you explain this? Wouldn't Hitler have been defending him if he was spreading nationalist propaganda? How would Hitler have made him disillusioned? Sounds weird. Thanks for the comment btw, good info here.

      I cut out some detail to not make the post too long. The 3 junior officers had been spreading propaganda specifically to encourage the soldiers not to fight against any revolution led by the NSDAP or other nationalist groups if it broke out - they were trying to encourage them to join any potential 'national revolution'. Hitler shocked them at the Ulm Reichswehr trial. He very famously used the trial as a platform to officially declare that his party was not seeking to overthrow the state, that he was trying to attain power legally - that after he was legally elected there would be a legal revolution and "heads would roll", but in the meantime the NSDAP was entirely law-abiding.

      Hitler's actions at the trial reassured a lot of ordinary citizens who were still worried about the NSDAP being too radical; they gave it a little bit more of a respectable veneer. But he pissed off a lot of the more revolutionary nationalists, who viewed cooperation with the system via elections as unbecoming or a betrayal. Scheringer saw it that way, but also saw it as Hitler basically throwing them under the bus - even though they'd been supporting the Party with their actions, and had been celebrated by & courted by the Party. Hitler's actions combined with other things which had discouraged him. Goebbels visited them all in prison, for example, and Scheringer was put off by him. At some point before the trial, too, he'd been given a tour of the newly-built Brown House in Munich (the official Party HQ) and was shocked at how grand and opulent it was, how many thousands of Marks had been spent on it while he knew there were so many penniless SA men out there who couldn't afford uniforms or proper meals. Ludin & Wendt were also very put off by Hitler at the trial, but Ludin decided to stick with the NSDAP & SA. He became an ambassador to Slovakia, which is why he was executed at the end of the War - he was accused of war crimes.

      [–]Nombre27 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

      Sadly reddit removed a bunch of stuff but Niekisch/Stennes (arplan.org guy) has posted redpills on this before.

      You know about the archives right?

      https://archive.org/details/DebateAltRight

      https://archive.org/details/DebateFascism

      Also a LOT more Communists became Nazis than the other way around, and the Nazis that did become Communist were basically just NazBols anyway.

      That's my conclusion too

      https://saidit.net/s/debatealtright/comments/7eg5/new_althype_vid_on_gabtv_the_nazicommunist/rw7r

      [–]JuliusCaesar225Nationalist + Socialist 3 insightful - 1 fun3 insightful - 0 fun4 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

      The 2 ideologies and the character of its proponents are diametrically opposed. However just because someone votes for one these parties when they were relevant in Germany would not make them a passionate ideological supporter of the cause. Therefore most of those who would switch were never truly "communists" or "nazis" in the first place, just casual voters switching sides.

      [–]Nombre27 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

      That's my take as well. I know AH mentioned the "No true Scotsman" fallacy but I think it's applicable in this instance as changing your vote is an exact demonstration that you don't agree with that party.

      [–]Nombre27 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

      edit: The table below is kind of wide, so if you want to see the entire table just zoom out and the screen will widen to accommodate it.

      I think he kind of refutes his own premise or has titled it incorrectly. Unless I'm misinterpreting (am I?), it seems more likely that there was a Communist to Nazi pipeline. Good summary just after 20 minute mark.

      Vote table with extra data from 1930 election. Added totals and vote counts. Data from wiki for these elections.

      1930 Election Vote % Count Change % July 1932 Vote % Count Change % November 1932 Vote % Count Change % March 1933 Vote % Count Change %
      NSDAP 18.25 6,379,672 15.69 NSDAP 37.27 13,745,680 19.02 NSDAP 33.09 11,737,395 -4.18 NSDAP 43.91 17,277,180 10.82
      SPD 24.53 8,575,244 -5.23 SPD 21.58 7,959,712 -2.55 SPD 20.43 7,251,690 -1.15 SPD 18.25 7,181,629 -2.18
      KPD 13.13 4,590,160 2.51 KPD 14.32 5,282,636 1.19 KPD 16.86 5,980,614 2.54 KPD 12.32 4,848,058 -4.54
      DNVP 7.03 2,457,686 -7.22 DNVP 5.91 2,178,024 -1.12 DNVP 8.34 3,792,563 2.43 DNVP 7.97 3,136,760 -0.37
      Liberal/Particular 37.06 13,221,737 -5.75 Liberal/Particular 20.92 7,996,029 -16.54 Liberal/Particular 21.28 6,995,997 0.36 Liberal/Particular 17.55 7,211,402 -3.73
      Total 100 35,224,499 0 Total 100 37,162,081 0 Total 100 35,758,259 0 Total 100 39,655,029 0

      Interesting is how the voting electorate shrank between July 1932 to November 1932 to March 1933, from 37.1M to 35.7M to 39.6M . Was this from purges or people leaving?

      November 1932, when the NSDAP lost votes (-2,008,285 for NSDAP), a maximum of 60% (+697,978 for KPD) of those ended up communist, assuming KPD got all their votes from NSDAP, which I think is doubtful but bear with me.

      March 1933, when the NSDAP was the only party listed to gain net votes, we see that the KPD lost 1,132,556 votes. The electorate increased 3,896,770 votes from November 1932 to March 1933 (silent majorityish? birthrates (seems too quick)?) while the NSDAP gained 5,539,785. The liberal/particular category also gained 215,405 votes from the previous election despite losing in voting percentage.

      So when the NSDAP lost votes, a maximum of 697,978 went communist, but when the NSDAP gained votes, a maximum of 1,132,556 communists voted NSDAP. So again, unless I'm misunderstanding things, it seems more like there was a communist to NSDAP pipeline than the other way around. So am I retarded?

      Also, I believe he mentioned the "No true Scotsman" fallacy. I think it's applicable here because I think it's valid to say that people who flip-flop on their voting aren't really members of either party that they're voting for as most party members will support the party that they actually believe. Might be a bit circular but I think it's valid.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1930_German_federal_election

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/July_1932_German_federal_election

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/November_1932_German_federal_election

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/March_1933_German_federal_election

      [–]cisheteroscumWhite Nationalist[S] 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

      Haven't watched it yet I hope it's a shitpost

      [–]EthnocratArcheofuturist 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (2 children)

      He's not on Bitchute?

      [–]cisheteroscumWhite Nationalist[S] 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

      He is but he advertised the Gab link on twitter

      Looks like he uploaded to both

      [–]EthnocratArcheofuturist 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

      Thanks.