I don't want to embrace an anti christian mentality because there are good christians in the movement and it is just as divisive as those who want to put christianity at the forefront of the movement. However I think it is misguided to try and fight the present by attempting to recreate the past. Absent of Christ himself returning I don't think Christianity can form the basis of Western Civilization again. When Rome adapted Christianity paganism was already dying and people were embracing various cults left and right. Monotheism was likely inevitable and I think the death of dogmatic religious is also inevitable.

Buddhism has shown that the religious foundation for a civilization does not need to be dogmatic or claim to be divine. I believe the West needs a new spiritual outlook that is non dogmatic. One that rejects the materialistic atheist view and sees the quest for understanding both the physical and metaphysical nature of existence as a moral virtue. You can somewhat blend paganism into this because eternal consciousness that is responsible for existence cannot be physically represented so it can be represented by pagan Gods in a symbolic way. The old gods can also be used as symbols of various moral virtues.