you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]ElectraHeart 13 insightful - 1 fun13 insightful - 0 fun14 insightful - 1 fun -  (2 children)

I don't know if i'm allowed to say this, but i always felt sad (not pity) for the yaoi gendies and hsts's. I was in Tumblr for a long time, since 2014 if i'm remembering correctly. I was there when all these gender nonsense started to pile up. In its essence, its just the tumblr model. Heterosexual girls in tumblr went from tolerance to glorification to appropriation to fanaticism. Now we're at the last stage, intolerance. Make no mistakes: they deserve to be in the prison they've built for themselves. But in the end, the heterosexual women's obsession with yaoi is just a reflection on how bad heterosexual men are.

If you were on tumblr when the "glorification" of gay men were ongoing, with mood / stimboards, kiss scenes, shipping wars, you'd understand it. Gays were thoughtful, caring, passionate and all that good traits, since media was too busy with "good representation". In contrast, these gendies started dating men, and saw the stark reality that is heterosexual men. Then they went "what if i had a boyfriend who is caring, passionate etc" and believed that the gay mens representation in the media (including yaoi) was actually the truth. I have a female friend that thinks gay men live like the manu rios couple in elite because she only consumes netflix content. And when she told me she wanted to go to a gay bar I was shocked. Like, its not whats shown on netflix girl.

Hence why I feel sad for them, they're women without any class consciousness. They will never admit that they are not gay men for liking caring and loving boyfriends but because they can't find a heterosexual men who won't degrade them. This still does not justify all the tricks they pulled off however, as they were the original gender priests for the cult, long before AGP men showed up.

[–]lunarstrain[S] 6 insightful - 1 fun6 insightful - 0 fun7 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

I don't know if i'm allowed to say this, but i always felt sad (not pity) for the yaoi gendies and hsts's.

I feel bad for HSTS, if gender identity disorder is a real thing then that's gotta suck. If it doesn't exist, then being that much of a self hating gay man/lesbian also sucks.

I was in Tumblr for a long time, since 2014 if i'm remembering correctly.

I can tell, based off of your user. That album was crazy popular back then, haha.

If you were on tumblr when the "glorification" of gay men were ongoing, with mood / stimboards, kiss scenes, shipping wars, you'd understand it.

Weirdly enough, I was. I actually joined a couple years earlier than you did. For me, that glorification seemed to stem from fetishization, rather than reverence in most users I saw. Same as the girls who were on DeviantArt and talking about nosebleeds from teh hawt yaoiz a couple years prior. Tumblr was a massive platform for teen girls at the time though, it's conceivable that we were exposed to two different groups of girls.

Gays were thoughtful, caring, passionate and all that good traits,

I'm a little confused about how they came to these conclusions, haha. Most yaoi I've seen, like the Japanese stuff, is more abusive than the average heterosexual relationship. I can think of a handful of titles that vividly feature rape right off the top of my head. That was the year Dramatical Murder was popular and that game is just gay rape porn. I read/watched a lot of yaoi when I was young because I thought that yuri was exclusively pornographic, and I wanted to see same sex relationships even if they weren't my sex. I had to stop reading/watching multiple series because of the blatant coercion/rape they showed.

As for the shipping side of things, the majority of those men/boys were not gay in canon. So, all of their homosexual interactions were written by other girls and everyone knew this. It's funny, what they really wanted in a man was a woman's perspective in a man's body.

I have a female friend that thinks gay men live like the manu rios couple in elite because she only consumes netflix content.

Netflix content is really weird.

This still does not justify all the tricks they pulled off however

Yeah, this is where any sympathy I have wanes. Auto-homosexuals have gotten more and more into the idea of rape by deception as time has gone on. They're generally not as bad as AGPs yet but they're trending in that direction.

[–]ElectraHeart 2 insightful - 1 fun2 insightful - 0 fun3 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

I'm a little confused about how they came to these conclusions, haha. Most yaoi I've seen, like the Japanese stuff, is even more abusive than the average heterosexual relationship. I can think of a handful of titles that vividly feature rape right off the top of my head. That was the year Dramatical Murder was popular and that game is just gay rape porn. I read/watched a lot of yaoi when I was young because I thought that yuri was exclusively pornographic, and I wanted to see same sex relationships even if they weren't my sex. I had to stop reading/watching multiple series because of the blatant coercion/rape they showed.

I was talking mostly about the media there, rather than yaoi. Stuff like Glee, Modern Family, Destiel, Remus / Sirius, Drarry, Stiles / Derek etc. It was a time that networks tried their best to show optimism, and also because they did not want to draw criticism due to 'stereotyping' gay people. I was more involved with shipping, as I was like #1 Stucky shipper. I miss 2015 - 2016 as the glory days of gay activism, with marriage equality and relatively small number of gendie talk. I remember the hashtag #givecaptainamericaaboyfriend and even though i had the two brain cells to realise it was never going to happen, i cherish the memory of millions of tweets by all the gay people across the world. Sometimes i do wish we could turn back time.

So much hope i have lost on gay rights, but the battle goes on.