you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

[–]MarkTwainiac 4 insightful - 1 fun4 insightful - 0 fun5 insightful - 1 fun -  (3 children)

  • Killing members of the group Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group
  • Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part

For many years, trans activists have been openly advocating that the above activities done to women, meaning female human beings, particularly those of a certain age, life experience and POV like Helen Joyce, JK Rowling, the women of Mumsnet and me.

In fact, some trans activists advocate that all "cis" people be put to death by grisly means such as "in a grease fire."

The activities below are exactly what many trans activists advocate be done to others in the "trans community":

  • Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group
  • Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group

You yourself have advocated subjecting all children and young people with gender and sex distress to medical treatments that will make it impossible for them to have children.

Trans activists routinely tell children sex and gender distress that their parents are their enemies, and advocate that they be forcibly removed from their families and handed over to adult gender activists who are part of "the LGBTQ+ rainbow community." Adult TRAs like Jeffrey Marsh and Rachel McKinnon/Veronica Ivy routinely use social media to tell kids they are their "new" mothers/parents/aunties now. TRAs who work in schools do everything they can to drive a wedge between children and their parents, telling kids that parents are distrustful and want to harm them. Thousands of anonymous adults seek out gender and sex confused kids online to groom them and turn them against their families, often encouraging them to reject their parents, run away from home, and to get their way by telling their parents that if they don't do exactly as the kids demand, the kids will commit suicide or take legal action accusing the parents of child abuse.

[–][deleted] 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (2 children)

For many years, trans activists have been openly advocating that the above activities done to women, meaning female human beings, particularly those of a certain age, life experience and POV like Helen Joyce, JK Rowling, the women of Mumsnet and me.

Are these people prominent? Like, I agree with you that that's awful, but I guess I don't see trans people with a platform threatening anyone. I know I don't, transness doesn't mean women won't exist.

Like if contra started saying to hurt women I'd be very disturbed and wouldn't support her. Helen Joyce is a prominent GC figure so she probably counts more than miscellaneous people with little power.

You yourself have advocated subjecting all children and young people with gender and sex distress to medical treatments

"Subjecting"? We choose to have those treatments, it shouldn't be forced on anyone.

Trans activists routinely tell children sex and gender distress that their parents are their enemies, and advocate that they be forcibly removed from their families and handed over to adult gender activists

Honestly this literally is the case half the time. Do you think that dysphoric kids should have to suffer under transphobic parents? That they should have to put up with their parents' religious drivel or them refusing to let their kid transition? That's how families are broken, mine and many others: parents unwilling to consider the autonomy and agency of their (often adult) children. If by removing someone from parental care they can transition or are happier then yes I totally support that. If you refuse to let your kid transition you're a bad parent, who should have had a pet instead of a human being if you needed that much control.

often encouraging them to reject their parents, run away from home, and to get their way by telling their parents that if they don't do exactly as the kids demand, the kids will commit suicide or take legal action accusing the parents of child abuse.

Again if the alternative is being controlled by their GC or religious parents and their dogma then I support them running away.

I know a woman whose parents test her monthly to make sure she doesn't take hormones and she can't leave because they help pay for college. If she did leave then according to most college financial aid rules in the US her parents' income would still be counted even if they contribute nothing. That's how it was for me too, my parents contributed nothing to my education but I had to beg them for tax documents every year or I couldn't keep going to university.

Situations like that make my heart break, honestly, and the parents inflicting that pain on people deserve very little respect. They should not have such control. If I could do it over again I would have never told my parents until I graduated and used them for all they were worth, knowing what I know now.

[–]MarkTwainiac 6 insightful - 1 fun6 insightful - 0 fun7 insightful - 1 fun -  (1 child)

Oy vey. I said:

You yourself have advocated subjecting all children and young people with gender and sex distress to medical treatments that will make it impossible for them to have children.

And you respond with:

"Subjecting"? We choose to have those treatments, it shouldn't be forced on anyone.

Once again, you've switched the subject from

all children and young people with gender and sex distress

To You and other adults like you!

Tell me, how did the individuals formerly known as Jaron Jennings and Xavier Neal choose the treatments they got when they were little boys? Jaron was 2 when his mother decided he was trans; he was 3 when officially given the label by a gender therapist. Xavier was a severely mentally ill and autistic boy age 4. Both were put on blockers when they were pre-teens. Both had their testicles removed and their penises surgically reconfigured when they were minors too young to give legal consent. One was 17; the other 16. How did they choose?

BTW, the Xavier Neal's two younger brothers have now become "trans girls" too - one in early primary school, the other in kindgergarten. Only one of their mother's four children is not trans - and that's probably linked to the fact that he's older, and has a disease that has been causing him to lose his sight, and he is now nearly totally blind.

Which raises an interesting point: not many trans people are blind. This seems to be an identity found almost exclusively amongst people with decent eyesight. Hmm, now why could that be?

[–][deleted] 1 insightful - 1 fun1 insightful - 0 fun2 insightful - 1 fun -  (0 children)

he was 3 when officially given the label by a gender therapist

Maybe the therapist guessed right, who's to say? Is there something wrong with a young kid socially transitioning? Like, I disagree with the model that prescribed blockers, I think people should be able to go on cross-sex hormones as teens but not earlier, and socially transition whenever.

Which raises an interesting point: not many trans people are blind. This seems to be an identity found almost exclusively amongst people with decent eyesight. Hmm, now why could that be?

Omigosh this is literally just conspiratorial confirmation bias lol. Sight is one of the most dysphoric senses but by far not the only one, someone could still have a lot of dysphoria over their voice or based on sensation.